Open letter to Egypt re inexplicable jailing of journalists

Al-Jazeera journalists (from left) Mohammed Fahmy, Peter Greste and Baher Mohamed.

Al-Jazeera journalists (from left) Mohamed Fahmy, Peter Greste and Baher Mohammed.

Aussie journos decry Egypt's detention of three Al Jazeera English reporters, including freelance Brisbane journalist Peter Greste

Leading Australian journalists express their disgust at the ongoing detention of three Al Jazeera English reporters in Egypt, including Brisbane freelance journalist Peter Greste. Source: Facebook

Mr Omar Metwally Mohamed Tawfic Metwally,
Egypt’s Ambassador to Australia

Trina McLellan
Journalist and educator, Queensland Australia

The wholly unfounded conviction of Australian journalist Peter Greste
and his two Al Jazeera English colleagues, Mohamed Fahmy and Baher Mohammed

June 23, 2014

Dear Sir

We have not had the privilege of meeting personally, however I would like to convey deep disquiet and displeasure about Monday’s ridiculous verdicts in the farcical trial of Brisbane freelance journalist Peter Greste and his Al Jazeera English colleagues Mohamed Fahmy and Baher Mohammed.

These three men had simply been doing their work as professional journalists for an international news organisation, one that continues to cover events in and outside of Egypt.

How a Cairo court could convict Peter Greste, an experienced and ethical freelance reporter, who had been reporting for Al Jazeera for just a couple of weeks, escapes any sensible explanation. He doesn’t even speak Arabic and there was no evidence presented in court that backed up the accusations levelled at him nor at his Canadian and Egyptian co-accused.

This sort of judicial behaviour in a well-established inquisitorial system makes a mockery of justice in your country and casts your nation in an incredibly negative light.

It appears that this has been little more than a show trial with an apparently pre-judged outcome, a cheap political stunt to garner domestic kudos at the expense of two foreigners and an Egyptian national who were just going about their work by covering all sides of a history-making story.

This sort of blatant partisan travesty paints Egypt in such a poor light and will doubtless have costly, unintended and unwanted economic, trade, tourism and diplomatic consequences.

I have been a journalist since 1981 and have never witnessed such an egregious misuse of judicial authority against reporters who were behaving professionally in the carriage of their duties.

I would like you to communicate the deep disappointment and disapproval of myself – and many of my Australian journalism and academic peers – to your country’s new Prime Minister, Mr Ibrahim Mahlab, as well as your new President, Mr Abdel Fattah el-Sisi and, through them, to the judiciary responsible for this outrageous verdict.

Perhaps an international court, or pressure from other sources, will put this matter right in time. But every single day those men remain in detention until then is a day your country remains in unmitigated shame.

Yours truly

Trina McLellan


If you would like to send a similar message to Egypt’s Ambassador to Australia,
you can email him at
and you can support these jailed journalists by signing
Amnesty International’s petition.

To support Peter Greste, Mohamed Fahmy and Baher Mohamed, sign Amnesty International's petition to free the three Al Jazeera English journalists. Screen shot: Amnesty International Australia Website

If you are reading this and want to support Peter Greste, Mohamed Fahmy and Baher Mohammed, please sign Amnesty International’s petition to free these three Al Jazeera English journalists. Screen shot: Amnesty International Australia Website

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s